Marble Hill is the answer to one of the classic trivia questions:
what is the only neighborhood in Manhattan that is part of the mainland? The neighborhood, immediately south of West 230th Street, once was part of York, or Manhattan Island, and was an area that was crossed by every visitor to New York who traveled by land. This is because the sole bridge connecting the island to the mainland was built here in 1693, across a creek called Spuyten Duyvil, The Devil’s Whirlpool, or “Spitting Devil.” The name, of Dutch origin, refers to the somewhat turbulent waters that characterized this convoluted meeting of the waters of the Harlem and Hudson Rivers. Not surprisingly, it was difficult to cross. As the narrowest crossing to the mainland, however, Spuyten Duyvil was destined to become an important transit area, and by the 1690s demand for a bridge to cross the tempestuous waters was high. The local landowner Frederick Philipse (originally Vriedrick Flipsen) took on the project of building a bridge across the creek from Manhattan to his property on the mainland in what is now the Kingsbridge neighborhood of the Bronx in 1693. Philipse did not build the bridge as a magnanimous gesture to the people of New York: as Sarah Knight indicated in 1704, the bridge was a profit-making enterprise: “about 5 we come to Spiting Devil, Else Kings bridge, where we pay three pence for passing over with a horse, which the man that keeps the Gate set up at the end of the Bridge receives.” (1) A second bridge, which was free to cross, was erected nearby in 1759 by Jacobus Dyckman and Benjamin Philips in response to numerous complaints by farmers about having to pay the toll. Both bridges are gone today, as is the Spuyten Duyvil Creek.
The creek was filled in after a larger ship channel was carved out of a preexisting small brook that roughly paralleled what would be 223rd Street. This canal, which obliterated the grid from 220th to 224th Street, allowed the passage of ships from Long Island Sound to the Hudson River. The outline of the former Spuyten Duyvil Creek remains only in the boundary line separating Marble Hill from the Bronx. Below is a map detailing the geographic changes to the area.
Manasseh Cutler’s biting remarks probably reflected the consensus opinion about the bridge: it was not particularly noteworthy except that everybody had to cross over it. There may still be a piece of the bridge under the asphalt near 230th Street and Kingsbridge Avenue, otherwise the bridge disappeared with the creek, leaving only the neighborhood name as a legacy. But it was almost always mentioned by travelers who had to cross it. (2)
King’s Bridge and Spuyten Duyvil. Below left is a map from Jenkins, The Story of The Bronx (1912, p.129) depicting the location of fortifications but also showing the various waterways and roads that crisscrossed the area of upper Manhattan and the Kingsbridge neighborhood of the Bronx. Broadway still exists, although Spuyten Duyvil creek was filled in shortly after his book was published. Below right is an image of unknown provenance showing King’s Bridge during the Revolutionary War. The image at lower right shows the original course of Spuyten Duyvil and the neighborhood of Marble Hill, part of Manhattan but now on the mainland. Bottom left is a photograph from Jenkins showing King’s Bridge as it looked in the late nineteenth century. Finally, the map at the very bottom is an excerpt from an 1836 map of New York, which shows the planned numbered streets of the city alongside the actual terrain and streets of the time. The small creek between 222nd and 223rd street was enlarged to create the Harlem River Shipping Channel in 1895. King’s Bridge is between 228th and 230th Streets, while the Dyckman Bridge was at 224th Street.
...